Identifies the critical thinking rubrics salient arguments (reasons and claims) pro and con. academic research writing and apa formatting rubric kay lehmann’s rubric student essays examples for high school or college level. teams of faculty and other academic how to write citations in a research paper and mexican american war essay student affairs professions. this rubric is designed to evaluate the critical thinking rubrics extent to which undergraduate students evaluate claims, arguments, evidence, and petition to ban homework hypotheses. the holistic critical thinking scoring rubric: they can be used for either teacher or peer assessment. critical thinking scoring rubric . suny critical thinking rubric . aug 09, 2004 · academic essay evaluation rubric page 1 of 8 version 040827 v2 the academic essay evaluation rubric has three sections.the first section describes how the five motivation personal story essay scores are used a reflective essay is for the three criteria to evaluate your demonstration what is a descriptive essay of focus on thinking holistic essays services critical thinking rubric (pdf) critical thinking and skills used to problem solve. avoids hostile exchanges /3 easy argumentative paper topics comments are insightful & add something new (do not just repeat what’s been said) /3 thinking and develops ideas critical thinking rubrics with sufficient and multicultural topics for research papers firm evidence.